Truck Conversion & Toterhome Community

Truck Conversion & Toterhome Community (https://www.truckconversion.net/forums/)
-   Truck Conversion General Discussions (https://www.truckconversion.net/forums/f104/)
-   -   Fuel MPG (https://www.truckconversion.net/forums/f104/fuel-mpg-7602/)

bushpilot 08-22-2016 09:38 AM

Fuel MPG
 
Im curious what others are getting...


We've been having some discussions and it seem i (mysteriously get good mpg)...admittedly i have a heavy foot, i have been typified (by more than one LEO) as an aggressive driver.

We are 42 feet, single rear axle, MBE 4000 (450hp) and ZF/Meritor 12 speed (manu-matic).

We tip the scale at 36k lbs (moderately loaded w/ fuel & 220g of fresh water), not including the ('12) Jeep Wrangler Sport (2 door soft top) that weighs in around 4200lbs

We consistently obtain 9.9 MPG, and have rarely seen lower than 8.0.

We have seen as high as 13 and change (low speed) secondary roads where we were barely able to maintain 60mph (fog & night driving) from Atlanta to Destin.

Towing 11k lb race/car trailer did not effect or mpg.

jasong 08-22-2016 10:15 AM

The fact the trailer did not effect you tells me your rat end gear is to low.

Kenn 08-22-2016 10:25 AM

fuel consumption
 
Don you do go a long way on a gallon of fuel. My rig is much older and smaller. 1982 Peterbilt 359 with a 450 hp Cummins STC (step timing control). The engine is a 1987. I have a 13 speed manual transmission with 336 rear end. I am 30' long and weigh just under 25 K loaded and tow a trailer 7K or Scion XB 2600 lbs. 1500 rpm in 8 th direct gives me 60 mph. My best has been 9.7 and worst 7.8 with an average around 8.8. I am sure that my big square bunk above the cab has bad aero drag and in a head wind I use more fuel. I try to end each trip with a fuel-up at the same fuel pump thinking that I would be more accurate with my fuel use. I don't have a gauge that shows real time fuel use so I run the engine where it feels like it is in a sweet spot.

bushpilot 08-22-2016 10:45 AM

I've just confirmed our coach came from Freightliner with a 3.21 rear

at 72mph we are turning just under 1500 rpm (sorry for the blurry picture, but all of these were taken w/ the cruise control set, no tricks)

72 MPH -> https://www.truckconversion.net/attac...49606d7746.jpg

65 MPH -> https://www.truckconversion.net/attac...9e745d9d7b.jpg

65 MPH -> https://www.truckconversion.net/attac...a940241450.jpg

bushpilot 08-22-2016 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasong (Post 46089)
The fact the trailer did not effect you tells me your rat end gear is to low.

I dont understand how you arrived at that, 6k (more lbs) then than jeep wrangler shouldn't really effect us.

a 10k lb trailer that is hidden in the air stream of the coach shouldn't really have any impact imo.

samcrimm 08-22-2016 10:39 PM

2 Attachment(s)
I don't know what my rear end is but I only get 65mph out of 1500 rpm, I have been wanting to get a picture but cant get the gps and the tach together and stay between the paint. I looked in the driver side door jams and did not see a gear ratio just wt info. Here are the pictures of the info I do have.

7 miles to the gal Sam

samcrimm 08-23-2016 06:00 PM

Been on the internet looking and wondering. Take a look at this, MERCEDES Tuning & Performance | MBE-4000 Highway Truck it deletes your EGR and if you have Def looks like it too. Any one heard of this? What do you think? I have local dealer that I called today and will get a price tomorrow so we can see how this factors into things.

Also my chassis is a 2003 and the RV a 2005. Wonder if that has something to do with mileage?

Sam

samcrimm 08-23-2016 09:06 PM

Found a pdf on the MBE 4000 performance and Economy here is link.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=...Uyq9Kg&cad=rja

Sam

38Chevy454 08-23-2016 11:24 PM

I have twin screw rear and 45 ft length and approx 36K lbs for the coach. Cummins ISX15 and 10 speed Eaton Ultrashift. I typically run 70-72 on interstates, which is about 1550 rpm for me. I think I have 3.36 rear gear, but have not ever really checked for sure. I don't regularly check mileage, but it is around 7 mpg. Mine is not aerodynamic, so I might do better if I drove slower. Usually towing a toad around 4K lbs, sometimes a trailer with car on it around 6K lbs. Toad or trailer does not make much difference in mpg, but can feel it when accelerating from a stop.

My engine has EGR, but no DPF or DEF. I have heard of 10-15% increase in mpg with an EGR delete, but nobody seems to have the real programming figured out to avoid the CEL and getting max performance potential.

RGulley 08-24-2016 10:58 PM

47 feet/41K Lbs/8 MPG running 71 MPH

samcrimm 08-24-2016 11:09 PM

Got the price today on the egr delete, the plug around 50.00 and the programing 2300!!

So, I was told more hp and torque helps on the mileage but just a little??

Sam

bushpilot 08-25-2016 07:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by samcrimm (Post 46094)
Been on the internet looking and wondering. Take a look at this, MERCEDES Tuning & Performance | MBE-4000 Highway Truck it deletes your EGR and if you have Def looks like it too. Any one heard of this? What do you think? I have local dealer that I called today and will get a price tomorrow so we can see how this factors into things.

Also my chassis is a 2003 and the RV a 2005. Wonder if that has something to do with mileage?

Sam

I wonder what they can do for non-emissions engines

Sam...you have an 03 engine, does it even have an EGR? My 03 engine (04 coach) does not have EGR.

Quote:

Originally Posted by samcrimm (Post 46108)
Got the price today on the egr delete, the plug around 50.00 and the programing 2300!!

So, I was told more hp and torque helps on the mileage but just a little??

Sam

at that price id want a guarantee!!!

i know any dealer can adjust HP/Tune, I've been thinking (forever) that id go get mine pumped up a little possibly and have then change the default starting gear (i start in 3rd & think i could start off fine in 5th or 6th gear).

id also have them remove the 72mph cruise (set) limit too.

petrel 08-25-2016 10:53 AM

Does the transmission have to be completely reprogrammed if you "tweak" the engine?

If I could have picked up 1.5 mpg on my last trip, I could have made a good down payment on the modifications. A little more shove would not be bad either. I used to be the fastest thing on a mountain with more than 8 wheels, until I got to AK. Those guys up there with the 650hp 18 speeds went by me like paint on a fence...pulling doubles!

samcrimm 08-25-2016 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bushpilot (Post 46113)
I wonder what they can do for non-emissions engines

Sam...you have an 03 engine, does it even have an EGR? My 03 engine (04 coach) does not have EGR.



at that price id want a guarantee!!!

i know any dealer can adjust HP/Tune, I've been thinking (forever) that id go get mine pumped up a little possibly and have then change the default starting gear (i start in 3rd & think i could start off fine in 5th or 6th gear).

id also have them remove the 72mph cruise (set) limit too.

NO EGR....so I was having fun for nothing I guess I should have looked under the hood first.

I am going to call the Freightliner dealer in Nashville tomorrow and ask about all that. I have never set my cruise over 70 that I can remember.....didn't know it had a limit.

I have also looked for programmers on line and they ain't cheap either.

Things to wonder about....

Sam

bushpilot 08-27-2016 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by samcrimm (Post 46118)
I am going to call the Freightliner dealer in Nashville tomorrow and ask about all that. I have never set my cruise over 70 that I can remember.....didn't know it had a limit.

yours might not, but i know mine won't set any higher than 71/72mph (gps verified), speedo indicated 70mph

Quote:

Originally Posted by samcrimm (Post 46118)
I have also looked for programmers on line and they ain't cheap either.

I think John (aka THUNDERUSONE) had dabbled with a bully dog and someone else, iirc the results weren't great and he returned it....as i also recall it was 800+ for the tuner

Quote:

Originally Posted by samcrimm (Post 46118)
Things to wonder about....

hey I'm just here to help you spend your money :D

solo318 08-29-2016 07:54 AM

If your going to spend the money, You should look at gears. . Most HDTs are geared to pull 80k pounds. Our trucks just don't carry that much. Upping the HP will make the engine work a little easier but it takes fuel to make HP.
Find out what RPM peak torque on your engine is and gear your truck to run that at your desired cruising speed You might have to downshift a little earlier on the hills but it will make your life a lot easier.
Rather than comparing engines/tuners/and such, compare top gear ratio/final drive/tire size. Speed is a factor in either case.

Bob86ZZ4 08-30-2016 09:21 PM

I think Freightliner puts the rear end ratio on a sticker on the inside of the fuse box cover? At least I think that's where I found mine.

Bob86ZZ4 08-30-2016 09:48 PM

Just got back from a 2800 mile trip. From Minnesota to Idaho and back. Lots of climbing/descending out there. I was pulling my enclosed trailer with a Honda Pilot in it. The Pilot is 4800 lbs. and my trailer empty is 3k lbs. Plus we threw a bunch of stuff in the trailer. It felt a lot heavier than when we're taking the Corvette to the track. I think I got 7.5 mpg for the lowest and 8.7 for the highest mpg calculations. I always fill up until it clicks off and do the math on paper. My speedometer and odometer are both off since I switched to 11R22.5 tires. They are a bit larger diameter than the original 275/80R/22.5 tires. When I switched to the larger tires it gave me a noticeable reduction in rpm's when cruising. But I also notice my speedo/odo are off. Checking speed with GPS shows when the speedo is showing 65 mph I'm actually going about 67-68. So that means that my miles are off. Which means I'm actually getting better mpg than what my math shows. I'm planning to contact the FL dealer to see if they can adjust my speedo/odo with a computer of something. When I'm cruising at a shown 66-67 mph my rpm's are about 1425-50.

samcrimm 08-30-2016 10:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob86ZZ4 (Post 46129)
Just got back from a 2800 mile trip. From Minnesota to Idaho and back. Lots of climbing/descending out there. I was pulling my enclosed trailer with a Honda Pilot in it. The Pilot is 4800 lbs. and my trailer empty is 3k lbs. Plus we threw a bunch of stuff in the trailer. It felt a lot heavier than when we're taking the Corvette to the track. I think I got 7.5 mpg for the lowest and 8.7 for the highest mpg calculations. I always fill up until it clicks off and do the math on paper. My speedometer and odometer are both off since I switched to 11R22.5 tires. They are a bit larger diameter than the original 275/80R/22.5 tires. When I switched to the larger tires it gave me a noticeable reduction in rpm's when cruising. But I also notice my speedo/odo are off. Checking speed with GPS shows when the speedo is showing 65 mph I'm actually going about 67-68. So that means that my miles are off. Which means I'm actually getting better mpg than what my math shows. I'm planning to contact the FL dealer to see if they can adjust my speedo/odo with a computer of something. When I'm cruising at a shown 66-67 mph my rpm's are about 1425-50.


My Speedo is off too and come to think of it, it makes a differents when I put the pencil to the mileage....mmm The speedo is like yours Bob gps 65 and showing 67 68. But I am turning 1500 at 65 gps. I under stand they are dip switches to change the speed. My fuse cover is blank.

Sam

bushpilot 08-31-2016 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob86ZZ4 (Post 46128)
I think Freightliner puts the rear end ratio on a sticker on the inside of the fuse box cover? At least I think that's where I found mine.

I found a build sheet in my (freight liner) packet -

https://www.truckconversion.net/attac...a83ca3c532.jpg

DeepVee 09-21-2016 02:38 PM

1998 Detroit Series 60 with an Eaton 13-speed in a 41' twin screw rig pulling a 10K lb enclosed trailer. My average bounces between 7.63 & 7.65 MPG according to the Detroit computer and depending on the hills. We pull at 66 MPH at around 1450 RPM's. I'd love to have a taller gear but just not sure it's worth the effort & cost to change them.

petrel 09-21-2016 03:20 PM

Based on everything I've read, I should be consistently doing better than 7mph, instead of hovering between 5 and 7. Some research on the trucking forums has given me about 20 different things to check.

I'm going to begin with finding a Detroit Diesel service center I think I can trust and getting them to read the computer setup and make sure all the parameters are right. After that, a search for intake leaks will be next.

Interestingly, one of Detroit Diesel's troubleshooting guides mentions an overfilled crankcase as causing a reduction in economy. I have had the oil changed in the rig three times since I purchased it, by two different Freightliner dealers. Each time they have overfilled it between 1/4 and 1/2 inch over full.

DeepVee 09-21-2016 06:11 PM

I've been putting 9-gallons of oil in my Series 60 with two of the big Baldwin filters.

petrel 09-22-2016 06:02 AM

It looks like both dealers I used added 9.5 gallons.

bushpilot 09-22-2016 06:49 AM

Just scored 8.57 on 588 miles last night - we cruised a steady 75 and saw 80+ more than I'd care to admit.

Driving was mixed mountainous wytheville va to maridian ms

bushpilot 09-22-2016 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bushpilot (Post 46164)
Just scored 8.57 on 588 miles last night - we cruised a steady 75 and saw 80+ more than I'd care to admit.

Driving was mixed mountainous wytheville va to maridian ms

I should add that we haven't run the 10k gen at all.

petrel 09-22-2016 09:27 AM

That is some great economy. I don't think the gennys burn more than about a half a gallon per hour, so I would not discount those numbers.

bushpilot 09-22-2016 02:06 PM

meridian ms to Baytown (Buc-ees) Tx

493 miles, 53.3 gal = 9.26 mpg
And cheap @ $1.79 per gallon

https://www.truckconversion.net/attac...b14e26e297.jpg

petrel 09-23-2016 05:58 AM

Had a conversation with a nearby DD service center representative yesterday. Hopefully, sometime in the next few weeks I'll get the rig in for an ECM settings check and a spin on the Dyno. I think we are in agreement that either a setting is wrong or there is an intake air leak.

bushpilot 09-23-2016 06:03 AM

Id love to know why my fuel BURN seems is so uneven.....13 gallons difference per side.

petrel 09-23-2016 08:51 AM

The draw down on my tanks is never uniform. I think some of it is in the fill. One nozzle shutting off before the other or tank position (tilt). The balancing is never perfect, and the genset draws from just one side.

bushpilot 09-23-2016 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by petrel (Post 46170)
The draw down on my tanks is never uniform. I think some of it is in the fill. One nozzle shutting off before the other or tank position (tilt). The balancing is never perfect, and the genset draws from just one side.

ok makes me feel better, thanks!

i have seen (when near bone dry), that i can have as much as a 20 gallon difference - where possible i try to fill one side at a time (even in a master / slave pump island) so that i can monitor the gallonage / consumption per side.

in the picture above you can see i only covered 500 miles (1/2 a tank on the dash/gauge) and was 13 gallons lower on the drivers side (where the float is).

Bottomland4x4 03-13-2017 03:13 PM

Just got back from a 1250 mile trip to Florida, pulling 21,000lbs I got a whopping 6.2 mpg! Had a terrible headwind down and back.

Java230 03-13-2017 04:17 PM

Man you guys are making me feel bad! My little F450 got 8.9 on my last trip.... Lots of passes and running 60-65 but still. I figured I would do better than you big trucks.

bushpilot 03-14-2017 04:37 PM

8.9 at 60/65 isnt anything to brag about....I get that at 72 with plenty of peaks to 78+
certainly headwinds will kill us all.

Java230 03-14-2017 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bushpilot (Post 46833)
8.9 at 60/65 isnt anything to brag about....I get that at 72 with plenty of peaks to 78+
certainly headwinds will kill us all.

Yeah thats what I was getting at, surprised your bigger trucks are doing so much better than mine.... I dont have a helpful rear end gear though. 4,88's are likely not helping. Im turning 2k rpms at 62

Bottomland4x4 04-17-2017 03:59 PM

Bush pilot, I wonder if the size of the bunk area has a lot to do with your mileage? Haulmark conversions usually have a smaller over bunk than the renegades, and I'm sure the aerodynamics have something to do with mileage. My toter was also an extended height which makes it less aerodynamic.

Bottomland4x4 05-24-2017 07:43 PM

My new to me, 2006 renegade 2800bm got 8.46 mpg coming from Nashville Tennessee to mt airy, nc. Not too bad for the hills. I found the gear ratio sticker near the fuse box and it is geared 3.21. This coach does have the egr. It feels more powerful than my old 16foot toter with a non egr Mercedes. This coach only has 26,000 miles so it's pretty new. We have our first trip planned for June 11th, headed to the beach. Last year my old renegade was showing 9.23mpg, so I will be anxious to see what the new coach does.

samcrimm 05-24-2017 08:22 PM

So Bottomland,

Did you buy the truck over in Hohenwald? If you did, I looked at his trucks and they were great, but I found a cheaper one in MS.

Sam

Bottomland4x4 05-24-2017 08:42 PM

No, I looked at his inventory on line and they were over my budget. I found mine on racing junk, it was only posted for 2 days when I found it. I feel like I of a really good deal. It was a one owner with only 26k miles, and was kept indoors. It only needed a really good cleaning and update the TV sets, it still had the original sony tube TV sets.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.